Keith Carradine and the
cast of "Paint Your Wagon."Photo: Joan Marcus
by Joel Benjamin
If I were forced at gunpoint (of
course!) to provide a one word description of the New York City Center Encores!
production of the 1951 Lerner and Loewe musical Paint Your Wagon, it
would be: robust. Continuing on that minimalistic path, I would add:
sexy, fresh, energetic and magical. Alan Jay Lerner (book and
lyrics) and Frederick Loewe (music), a most unlikely urban, urbane duo,
fashioned a totally original 19th Century period musical. Encores!
has taken Paint Your Wagon and given it a contemporary spin, with much
emphasis on the testosterone-tinged sensuality of the book and songs, something
not possible back in 1951. Director Marc Bruni has found all the nuances
in Lerner’s libretto and Denis Jones has produced hearty dance sequences that
are not only entertaining, but keep the momentum flowing. And, of course,
the fabulous Rob Berman, conducting the Encores! Orchestra in Ted
Royal’s original orchestrations, gave the show a generous, full-bodied sound.
Set in various fly-by-night gold
rush towns inhabited by colorful characters, Wagon centers around Ben
Rumson (a richly layered performance by Keith Carradine), a charismatic,
grizzled old-timer with a charming teenage daughter, Jennifer (a vivacious and
totally wonderful Alexandra Socha). Jennifer falls for Latin heartthrob
Julio Valveras (Justin Guarini in a marvelously suave performance).
Justin Guarini and Alexandra Socha
Lerner populated the show with a
rainbow of ethnic types: Englishman Edgar Crocker (a low-keyed, but slick
Adam Monley); energetic Irishman Mike Mooney (a perfect, cliché-free Robert
Creighton) was the de facto mascot of the rowdy miners; French
showgirl/madam Cherry Jourdel (Robyn Hurder, voluptuous and funny) who, at the
urging of Jake Whippany (multi-talented Caleb Damschroder, who sang, danced and
played the banjo) brings her girls to the sex-starved miners; and Mormons Jacob
Woodling (William Youmans, making this man quite appealing) and his two wives,
Sarah (Melissa van der Schyff, properly stuffy, but appealing) and Elizabeth
(Jenni Barber, giddily wonderful as she leaves Jacob for Ben and then for
Edgar!).
From the propulsive “I’m On My
Way” which brought all the characters together in the new town of Rumson to the
languid Latin love song, “I Talk to the Trees,” Lerner and Loewe molded their
talents to this alien setting. Ms. Socha’s girlish “What’s Goin’ On
Here?” enchantingly displayed her naïve confusion at all the males in town
avoiding her maturing, but verboten body. Keith Carradine had
several bittersweet ballads: “I Still See Elisa,” a lovely homage to his
late wife and “Wand’rin’ Star,” his philosophy of an unsettled life. Nathaniel
Hackmann, boyishly handsome and sexy, led the men in one of the big hits from
the show “They Call the Wind Maria.” There were wistful songs (“Another
Autumn”), eccentrically funny songs (“Hand Me Down that Can O’Beans”) and
entertaining interludes (“Can-Can”). In other words, a score that should
never have been neglected so long.
Anna Louizos’s scenery, including
a glorious backdrop of silhouetted pine trees was ingenious. Alejo
Vietti’s costumes perfectly suited each character and the period.
The regular Encores!
season concludes with Zorba! (May 6-10) and continues in the summer with
Off-Center which includes A New Brain, Little Shop of Horrors
and Andrew Lippa’s The Wild Party. Check the New York City Center
website for details.
New York City Center Encores!
Paint Your Wagon – March
18-22, 2015
New York City Center
131 West 55th St. –
between 6th & 7th Avenues
New York, NY
Tickets and Information:
212-581-1212 or www.NYCityCenter.org
Running time: 2 hours 15
minutes, one intermission