Jonathan Groff & Aaron Lazar photos
by Joan Marcus
by Julia Polonsky
Bravo to all the artists involved in re-imagining and updating
William Finn’s A New Brain for Encores! Off-Center. The
endlessly talented James Lapine not only co-authored A New Brain,
but directs this production, with gusto and brio and smashing style. Encores!
Off Center productions, which are effectively staged readings on
steroids, work their minimalist sets hard. In this case, scenic designer
Donyale Werle makes the most of a piano, a gurney, a bench, and a bizarre MRI
coffin. The choreography, by Josh Prince, does a great job of emphasizing the
hallucinatory feeling of much of the show.
William Finn does witty, clever patter songs better than anyone. A
New Brain serves them up, one after another, making killingly funny
art of a disastrous time in his life. The libretto – the show is sung-through,
with small splashes of dialogue sprinkled here and there – tells the story of
Gordon Michael Schwinn, (Jonathan Groff) a struggling songwriter with a
nightmare job, writing for a kiddie show. He has to be upbeat. He has to rhyme.
He hates it. He has a best friend (Alyse Alan Louis), a mother (Ana Gasteyer),
a boyfriend (Aaron Lazar), and a nightmare boss -- an oversize frog
named Mr. Bungee (Dan Fogler) who appears in hallucinations and dream
sequences, berating, belittling, and threatening Gordo.
….with Ana Gasteyer
He also has an arteriovenous malformation in his brain (try
rhyming that), and when he suddenly passes out in public, the rest
of the show sings of hospitals, tests, MRI, surgery, recovery. A New
Brainshows us love and abandonment, and family, and fear and how we cope
with it (some of us go sailing; some of us send our lover home and get to work
writing one last song, some of us put on rubber gloves and clean the apartment
and throw out books). Above all, it shows how we change, when the Big Things
happen.
Most of the songs are quite good. Perhaps it’s petty to cavil at
them mostly sounding melodically similar, but they do. However, among the
splendid highlights: a lovely song about songs, “Heart and Music.” The
ensemble work on “Gordo’s Law of Genetics,” segueing into “And They’re Off.” A
brace of songs for the “nice nurse” (Josh Lamon): “Poor, Unsuccessful, and Fat”
and “You Boys Are Gonna Get Me In Such Trouble.”
It may also be petty to kvetch about the pacing, but there it is.
The show itself is written in long stretches of frantic, with slower moments
that feel like lulls, instead of lovely opportunities for reflection.
What works really, really well: the frame for the story arc. A
homeless lady, (Rema Webb) asks for change. “Pennies, nickels, and dimes,” she
sings, when we first meet her, and as the show goes deeper, her demand for
change parallels Gordo’s experiences as he almost dies, then recovers. She’s
Greek chorus, therapist, and revenge incarnate, all delivered in one
showstoppingly excellent performance.
Other memorable performances: Quentin Earl Darrington as The
Minister, and Bradley Dean as Dr. Jafar Berensteiner, who gets one of the
biggest laughs in the show.
Kudos to Encores! Off-Center for
bringing back A New Brain, a creative, boundary-pushing Off-Broadway
musical about. Bringing back such musicals makes the theater scene in New York
a more interesting, better place.
A New Brain at Encores! Off-Center
June 24 – 27, 2015
New York City Center
West 55th Street between 6th and 7th Avenues
nycitycenter.org
Little Shop of Horrors
Jul 1 - 2, 2015
The Wild Party
Jul 15 - 18, 2015