Jason Robert Brown, Alfred Uhry, Steve Oney, Julie Burstein
Photography by Melanie Einzig / Museum of Jewish Heritage
by Rachel Goddard
Bringing history to the stage was the theme for the evening and
the subject was the Broadway musical Parade, the 1999 Tony Award Winner
for Best Book of a Musical and Best Score. “An Evening on Parade” was an
absolute dream for any theatre, music, or history lover. The evening featured
the writers of Parade, three-time Tony Award-winning composer/lyricist
Jason Robert Brown and Pulitzer Prize recipient, book-writer Alfred Uhry. Steve
Oney joined the panel as the principal historian of the 1915 murder trial of
Leo Frank, the only man of Jewish faith to be lynched unjustly for murder, the
story that inspired Parade.
Jason Robert Brown
photos by Melanie Einzig
Between the Q&A and discussion moderated by, Peabody Award-winner
Julie Burstein, featured performances of songs from the musical. Jason Robert
Brown conducted a ten-piece orchestra of his own score while Broadway favorites
performed ten of the numbers from the Parade. Broadway sweethearts
Stephanie J. Block and Sebastian Arcelus sang the principle roles of Leo and
Lucille Frank and Broadway's Jesse Warren-Nager, Caitlin Houlihan, Caitlin
Kinnunen, and Allie Trimm completed the cast of gifted actors.
The audience seemed to be composed of mostly eager theatre fans,
most of whom had never set foot in this museum before. Many in attendance
seemed more than familiar with Parade, a musical not quite commercially
popular, but greatly honored by any musical theatre disciple. While the
discussion that would follow would be predominantly around the historical
events, with Steve Oney contributing the greatest to the conversation, the other
real luxury of the evening was hearing the music of Jason Robert Brown.
Stephanie Block, Sebastian Arcelus,
Jesse Warren-Nager gave an energetic and convincing performance of
Jim Conley, the African-American man who testified against Leo Frank. The main
character of Parade is a challenge for any actor both vocally and
emotionally but Sebastian Arcelus gave a vulnerable and dynamic, albeit
polished, performance of Leo Frank, exhibiting his and the composer’s
versatility by switching between the imaginary character described by Jon
Conley as a seducer, removing his jacket and glasses
in a jazzy rendition of ” Come Up to My
Office", to which the trio of young girl factory workers attested, then
reverting back to the tight collared emotionally repressed factory
superintendent.
Stephanie J. Block joined him showing off her big Broadway voice
captivating the audience with her compelling and unaffected performances.
Watching them sing with a genuine enjoyment of the music and story was the
perfect supplement to the historical discussions that dominated the night. If
the audience already wasn’t invested in this story, they were by the end of the
first three numbers, proving the message of the night to be true; that theatre
can bring a historical story back to life in the most emotionally gripping way.
Much to the anticipation of the audience, Stephanie J. Block gets
a chance to show off her vocal magic in “You Don’t Know This Man” heightening
the already sky-high intensity of the story felt in the room. Arcelus singing
Leo Frank’s testimony song, “It’s Hard to speak my Heart” only adds to the
emotion. After he finished, sounds of audience members sniffling lingered into
the next part of the dialogue. At the point in the evening the façade of
theatricality slowly slipped off and the reality of the story affected everyone
in the room.
The last two songs performed were, “This is Not Over Yet” and “All
the Wasted Time”, sung by the two principals as they believed he would be
exonerated, just before he was lynched, which gave the audience some of the
most tender moments between real-life husband and wife Arcelus and Block. The
room continued to melt as Block looked adoringly at Arclelus singing. Hearing
it sung by a couple who didn’t have to forge their romance only highlighted the
honesty and veracity of the musical Brown and Uhry created. The last number
ended with Arcelus giving his wife a perfectly sweet and seemingly impromptu
kiss, proving the enthralling effect this story told through this music has on
anyone.
Topics of discussion were greatly around the question, “What
inspired you to write this musical?” a question Jason Robert Brown seemed to be
baffled by. “Why wouldn’t we write this?” Brown said plainly, bringing up even
more miserable musicals that have come before it like Sweeney Todd and Les
Miserables. The need for a musical was obvious to him, although he
confessed that the principle role of Leo Frank was difficult to musicalize and
write songs for him that were satisfying to listen to. (And if you haven’t
listened to Parade, he obviously overcame that challenge.)
Uhry had more of a personal connection to the story. Uhry, raised
in Georgia, grew up with the story of Leo Frank being commonly referenced but
never fully explained. He even knew Lucille Frank growing up, saying she was a
friend of his grandmothers. He said he didn’t realize the significance of his
connection, “any friend of your grandmother’s is just another old lady” he
joked. Uhry recalls many times asking to hear more and a “never mind” was all
he received. Steve Oney also concurred that the Jewish community felt this
event to be taboo and repressed it out of fear.
They also answered the question of why a musical, which takes
place in 1915, would begin during the civil war. Uhry stressed the importance
of “getting to the route of the anger” in which the South still felt “occupied”
by Northerners, embodied by Leo, a New York Jew in their midst. The “Old Red
Hills of Home” the prologue to the musical, was the first song written and Uhry
said it perfectly encapsulated how he felt about Georgia and almost brought him
to tears the first time he heard it.
The relevance of this story today was the final topic. Oney’s opinion
was that injustice occurred then because those involved of different
backgrounds were “speaking culturally past each other, making it near impossible
to know the truth” a familiar issue still today. Jason Robert Brown’s answer
for why this story is significant included a subtle jab at Donald Trump
referring to him as a “racist demi-god”. The audience gave a loud laugh of approval,
not needing any further justification for why this musical and story is still essential.
Uhry and Brown revealed that they attended a school performance of
Parade, with some apprehension, in Marietta, Georgia where they
met the great-niece of the little girl who was murdered, Mary Fagan. She
believed, despite what the musical believed, and the stunning revelations by Steve
Oney’s post trail research putting the blame for Mary’s death squarely on Jim
Conley, that Leo Frank in fact murdered her great Aunt. (In fact the lynch mob
was comprised of the town's leading and unapologetic citizens) “She’s fine,”
quipped Brown easing the tension the audience had been building all night. “It
was all so dramatic” Uhry said, which is exactly what the audience had gathered
as they learned that the original story was just as intoxicating as the music
created to enhance it.
“An Evening on Parade” rarely lost their audience’s attention. The
evening achieved its goal to be educational and entertaining and made yet another
case for not only the success but the importance of history-inspired musicals
with specifics on how the brilliant collaborators of Parade reached
their objective and brought the heartbreaking story of Leo Frank to life.
The evening was made possible by the Museum of Jewish Heritage in
association with the National Yiddish Theatre Folksbiene
Museum of Jewish Heritage
36 Battery Pl, New York, NY, 10280
(646) 437-4202
Seeking Justice: The Leo Frank Case Revisited can be
viewed at the Museum of Jewish history through August 2016. http://www.mjhnyc.org/e_nowonview_leofrank.html
www.nytf.org
Upcoming events:
An Evening with Toby and Itzhak Perlman and The Perlman Music Program
Wednesday, March 16, 7 P.M.
A Joyful Purim
Wednesday, March 23, 7:30 P.M.
Dudu Fisher in "Jerusalem"
NYC PREMIERE—THREE NIGHTS ONLY
Sunday, March 27, 3 P.M.
Monday, March 28, 7:30 P.M.
Wednesday, March 30, 7:30 P.M.