Pictured (l-r): Blake Hammond, Jerry O'Connell, Renée Fleming, Douglas Sills, Scott Robertson, Anna Chlumsky. Photo Credit © 2015 Andrew Eccles
By Russell Bouthiller
Making
her Broadway debut, three-time Grammy winning opera star Renée Fleming takes to the
stage of the Longacre Theatre in the new play by two-time Tony winner Joe
DiPietro, Living on Love, inspired by the Garson Kanin work, Peccadillo.
Also starring Douglas Sills and directed by Tony winner Kathleen Marshall, this
screwball comedy takes a look at romance among the upper registers.
Pictured: Douglas Sills as Vito De Angelis & Renée as Raquel De Angelis
Credit © 2015 Joan Marcus
Set
in an elegant mid-century penthouse, designed richly by Derek McLane, Living
on Love opens with young writer Robert Samson (Jerry O’Connell) waiting impatiently
for the maestro Vito De Angelis (Sills) to emerge from his bedroom. It is mid
afternoon and they had a morning appointment.
Samson
has been hired to ghostwrite De Angelis’s memoirs and there has not been a
great deal of progress. Snooping through things, Samson discovers an album of
“Tosca,” performed by the conductor’s famous diva wife, Raquel (Fleming).
Alone on stage, Samson states to no one in good expository fashion that this is
a rare recording. Of course, you know that it will be smashed later on.
Predictability starts early in this play. Thus, indulging his passion, Samson
plays the record, mouthing the libretto in grand mock performance. Meanwhile
upstage, the disheveled maestro makes his entrance.
With
an accent that is supposed to be Italian—it’s about as Italian as Ramen noodles—Sills
delivers every line at such a high decibel, you’d think he was aiming for the
furthest seat in the family circle. It’s as if someone were whispering in his
ear, “there’s no such thing as a small gesture.” That someone may well be
director Marshall who has every one of the actors over-emphasizing at every
possible instance.
Mugging
and preening and posing and gesticulating can all be great fun when there is a
script underneath to support the players. In this case, the player seems to be
there to support the script, which, at its core, has jokes that are short on
laughs and long in the tooth.
Surprisingly,
Renée Fleming, the famed opera star, the player who might seem out of her
element is the most comfortable on stage, though the character seems a distant
reflection of the person playing it. Firstly, there is nothing inventive or
new or challenging about an opera singer who is self-absorbed. Let’s face it:
we don’t think of the word “diva” and envision a frumpy woman serving at a soup
kitchen. But Fleming gives an appealing performance and is the equivalent to
an EMT first responder to a theatrical disaster. She looks good in Michael
Krass’s gowns as well.
Pictured: Jerry O'Connell aas Robert Samson & Anna Chlumsky as Iris Peabody
Credit © 2015 Joan Marcus
Jerry
O’Connell holds back a bit more than Sills, but his character is as equally
silly and his impersonation of the diva at the beginning of the play makes it
somewhat incredulous, later on, when he goes after his replacement ghostwriter,
Iris Peabody, played with noble control by Anna Chlumsky. Samson goes on to ghostwrite
for Raquel’s memoirs, which is utterly implausible. And, rounding out the
cast, Blake Hammond and Scott Roberson are Bruce and Eric, two servants who
provide a last-minute shoehorned subplot.
In
the end, miraculously, lothario husband Vito and the not-so-bad-after-all
Raquel give up their futile romantic dalliances with their ghostwriters and
come to appreciate each other. They kiss at the end, as all good comedies
provide.
The Longacre Theatre
220 West 48th St. (just west of
Broadway)
New York, NY
Tickets: 877-250-2929 or www.Ticketmaster.com
More Information: www.livingonlovebroadway.com
Running
time: 2 hrs; one intermission