C.J.
Wilson and Mary McCann star in Simon Stephens's On the Shore of the
Wide World, directed by Neil Pepe, at Atlantic Theater Company.
(© Ahron R. Foster)
By Ron Cohen
“it’s really
difficult, isn’t it?... Just, the whole business of, you know, being alive.
Very complicated,” says a loquacious cab driver toward the close of Simon
Stephens’ family drama On the Shore of the Wide World.
It’s hardly
an original point, but it’s one that Stephens illustrates with poignant
credibility as he draws us quietly and steadily into three generations of a
fairly quotidian English family, living on the outskirts of Manchester. The
Atlantic Theater Company production is devoid of the astounding theatrical
effects that marked Stephens’ 2015 Tony-winning adaptation of the novel The
Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, which ran on Broadway for
two years, but it provides a similarly gratifying if tamer experience.
C.J.
Wilson plays Peter and Ameila Workman plays Susan in On the Shore of
the Wide World.
(© Ahron R. Foster)
The family in
question consists of Peter and Alice Holmes; their sons, 18-year-old Alex and
15-year-old Christopher, and Peter’s father and mother, Charlie and Ellen.
During the time period of less than a year covered by the play, they move
through a maze of complications and challenges.
On the
lighter side, we find Peter and Alice at the play’s start dealing with their
decision to allow Alex’s girlfriend, Sarah, to spend the night in Alex’s room.
It’s a decision complicated by Christopher’s massive crush on Sarah.
Mary
McCann plays Alice and Leroy McClain plays John in On the Shore of the
Wide World.
(© Ahron R. Foster)
But along
with this realization of their offspring’s maturity -- their looking to a wider
world -- come steeper challenges. There are the intimations that their own
marriage has grown stale, the destructive lure of marital infidelity, uneasy
reverberations between Charlie and Ellen and the vicissitudes of age and
illness. All of this and more is deepened by the intrusion of sudden tragedy,
coming so unexpectedly that when it’s revealed, almost matter-of-factly, it’s a
total shocker.
There are
compellingly explosive moments, to be sure, but what also grabs you – perhaps
even more -- is the understated web of feeling and enduring attachments created
in Stephens writing and beautifully realized by the cast under Neil Pepe’s sure
but sensitive direction. Whatever the problems, we see people somehow getting
through and often enjoying the ephemera of daily life, having breakfast,
talking about soccer players, watching television.
At the center
of the play is C.J. Wilson’s splendid portrayal of Peter, a man who has trouble
expressing the love he has for his wife and children, but nevertheless
demonstrates it in so many ways. The tenderness and concern come to the fore
even when he quickly wraps a bacon sandwich for Christopher to take on a morning
bike ride. And it’s there when he hands over cash to Alex for his move to London
with Sarah, another element adding to the distress of Peter and Alice.
Wilson also shows us a guy of integrity with
a passion for his work as a house restorer, the business he took over from his
father. It’s an integrity to family as well, as we watch him controlling the
sexual tension while conversing with a comely, if pregnant, customer (nicely
played by Amelia Workman) about the job he can do in fixing her home.
As Alice,
Mary McCann movingly reveals the unease taking over her psyche, while
demonstrating the womanly charm that keeps Peter in her orbit. Those charms
fairly blossom in conversations with a new acquaintance, a man drawn to her
through unfortunate circumstances, and sympathetically limned by Leroy McClain.
Ben Rosenfeld
and Wesley Zurick deliver well-defined portraits, respectively, of the somewhat
reserved Alex and the precocious Christopher, while Tedra Millan bubbles with
frothy charm as Sarah.
Peter Maloney
and Blair Brown bring depth and authority to their portrayals of Charlie,
crusty and prone to drinking but affectionate, and Ellen, pondering the
direction of her life. Completing the cast is Odiseas Georgiadis as the
magnetic pal who lures Alex and Sarah to London.
The story
travels over numerous locales – the two homes, a deserted hotel that the
younger generation uses as a hangout, and various other spots around the town.
Pepe’s adroit staging and Stephens’ dialogue keep things fairly evident, as
Christopher Akerlind’s lights come up to define different areas of Scott Pask’s
atmospheric bi-level set.
What isn’t
always clear is the time frame of the scenes, and it may take some sharp
attention to the dialogue or simply a leap of faith to discern or settle into
what’s going on as a new scene begins.
What is
clear, however, is Stephens’ deep compassion for his characters, his artfulness
in bringing them to life and making you feel for them, widening your own
emotional expanse. And that’s an ages-old reason to go the theater.
Off-Broadway
play
Playing at
Atlantic Theater Company’s Linda Gross Theater
336 West 20th
Street
866-811-4111
atlantictheater.org
Playing until
October 8