Elizabeth Claire Walker and Daniel Applebaum in
"Anomie," photo by Nir Arieli
By R. Pikser
Claudia Schreier’s evening of works at the Ailey Center was the
culmination of her year-long mentorship by The Breaking Glass Project, started
in 2013 in New York by Ellenore P. Scott of ELSCO Dance and Nathalie Matychak
of MATYCHAK and extended to Los Angeles in 2014. The Project’s goal is to help
female choreographers reach their full potential; to this end, award recipients
receive a year of artistic and organizational mentorship.
The evening’s pieces, which included three world premieres, two of
them performed to live music, enjoyed the participation of members of some of
the most prestigious ballet companies in the United States: American Ballet
Theatre, Dance Theatre of Harlem, the Los Angeles Ballet, the New York City
Ballet, and the Suzanne Farrell Ballet, all of them technically impeccable.
Ms. Schreier’s work at this point in her career owes much to
Balanchine: there are many arabesques and extensions; movement is quick; lines
are clear, sculpture intertwines the dancers. The whole forms a visually
satisfying intellectual puzzle that is hard to grasp in one, or even two
viewings.
Amber Neff
& Drew Grant in "Almost Morning," photo by Nir Arieli
The music that Ms. Schreier seems to prefer, whether of American
Jeffrey Beal, or Dutch Douwe Eisenga has a driving underbeat that dominates
melody; unfortunately this style of music did not provide the dancers with
stimulation to explore different approaches to their movement. Even in the two
pieces performed to Franck (Anomie) or to de Victoria and Rachmaninoff (Vigil),
there was little interplay between the choreography and the music. In the
premiere Vigil, though the chorus, Tapestry, was arranged in a
semi-circle on stage behind the two soloists, the singers and the dancers
seemed to occupy two separate, if contiguous, worlds, rather than being part of
one integrated theatrical experience. The same criticism may be made of the
premiere of Almost Morning to Jeff Beal’s Almost Morning, also
premiered on this evening. The piano quartet, placed in the upstage right
corner of the stage, occupied the most powerful visual stage position in
cultures that read from top to bottom, left to right; yet the musicians were
never included in the choreography. If the musicians dominate the stage, why
does the choreography ignore them?
Elinor
Hitt and Da'Von Doane in "Vigil" photo by Nir Arieli
In fact, throughout the evening, in spite of the many interesting
formal interplays in partnering and staging, the dancers barely related to each
other. Drew Grant was the exception to this rule: Every time he placed a hand
on a partner or looked at someone, it was almost a seduction. He created
relationships on the stage. De’Von Doane’s energies and pleasure in dancing
left the stage to be warmly projected outward to the audience.
Anomie, a piece from 2009 was interesting because Ms. Schreier’s varied
her style. The piece began and ended with two suggestive partnering sculptures
that hinted at an emotional underpinning. The movement attempted to
incorporate fluid body movements and curves into the choreography. The subtext
of the piece could have been love, or loss, or longing, or even playfulness.
Though the dancers, especially Mr. Grant and Lydia Wellington, seemed to be at
the point of going beyond the pure movement to a more complex level of
interpretation, no one found a way of initiating movement from the center of
the body as the choreography seemed to cry out for.
The final piece of the evening, another premiere, also to music by
Mr. Eisenga, had the largest cast and showed Ms. Schreier’s considerable
intellectual abilities to their best advantage. Entrances and exits flowed
seamlessly from the movement, as the dancers picked up or paralleled each
others’ movements; combinations and recombinations of shapes and groupings were
dazzling in their variety; and the movement, though cleanly modern was almost
Baroque in the fugal complexity of its structuring. Another plus in this was
the presences of Nayara Lopes who, for all the speed and complexity of
movement, managed to revel in her dancing and to help us remember that dance
derives from the ecstatic.
Ms. Schreier is clearly talented and her intellect is impressive.
However, her work could be so much richer if there were more exploration
between the dancers, between the dancers and the musicians, and between the
dancers and the subtext that seems to be suggested by the pieces.
Breaking Glass Project
Claudia Schreier & Company
August 8th, 2015
Ailey Citigroup Theatre
409 West 55th Street
New York, NY
Tickets $20; $15 for students and seniors Proceeds to support the
Breaking Glass Project
www.claudiaschreier.com