Ben Schnetzer, Holly
Hunter, Bill Pullman and (standing) Raviv Ullman Photos: Monique
Carboni
by David Schultz
A revival of
playwright David Rabe’s Tony Award winning play Sticks and Bones (1971) may
prove to be the most moving and gut wrenching play in New York City at the
moment. This seriously demented twist on the Ozzie and Harriet T.V. clan, circa
1968, during the height of the Vietnam War still cuts deep. Every generation
has its wars and war heroes, as well as its forgotten unsung soldiers.
The play is set in a
very specific time and place (1968), but the parallel to soldiers returning
from the more recent wars in Afghanistan and Iraq is quite resonant. Bill
Pullman and Holly Hunter are the picture perfect couple. They inhabit the roles
of Ozzie and Harriet with measured cadences and speak in a zippy repartee; very
reminiscent of the way the television couple spoke in the golden age of the
1950’s era. Equally in sync with the frothy family is son Rick (Raviv Ullman),
chirping with a short staccato verbal style, which amuses at first, then
assumes a sinister undercurrent as the play evolves.
Holly Hunter and Bill
Pullman
The characters all
seem a bit too animated, a bit too shrill and a bit fearful of what condition
son David (Ben Schnetzer) will be in, on his return from the Vietnam War. This
sets into motion the return of the war hero to the homestead. All hopes are
shattered upon the return in the early scenes of the play. David returns,
shell-shocked and blind. His emotional state is frayed and he is consumed with
a deep-seated anger at what he experienced, and even more so at the total
mindlessness and apparent shallow welcome he receives from his picture perfect
family. The more the family seeks to comfort and placate David, the more his
anger boils to the surface. They hope to stave off his inner demons with
religious help from Father Donald (Richard Chamberlain) to no avail. David
conjures the image of a woman he had a brief relationship with back in Nam.
This ethereal woman named Zung (Nadia Gan) doesn’t speak, until a brief scene
later. She alone seems to calm his inner demons.
This brief synopsis
doesn’t do justice to the many-layered nuances that Mr. Rabe has written into
the script. From top to bottom, this impeccable play has been blessed with
articulate acting from the entire cast. Director Scott Elliott amazes with
unswerving pitch-black comedy that slides into horrific emotional scenes in
quick succession…so fast at times its hard to catch your breath. This hard-to-pin-down,
what comes next roller coaster masterpiece is the opposite of comfort food.
The achingly accurate
living room set design by Derek McLane is perfection. The floral printed couch,
overstuffed barco-lounger chair, wood paneling, garish orange doors and
latticework backdrop speak volumes of taste or lack thereof. A wide staircase
stage right ascends to the second floor of the house, where we are privy to the
collage-dorm-like room of son David. It is there that he escapes his cheerful
family, with occasional visits from the ghostly Zung. Costume designer Susan
Hilferty perfectly captures the look and tacky vibe of the late 60’s. Lighting
designer Peter Kaczorowski bathes the proceedings in bright hues; but does
darken the tone, literally and figuratively with a mesmerizing lighting effect
during one of Mr. Pullman’s darker inner dialogues. Director Scott Elliott has
a clear vision of what this play is about. The amazing thing is everyone on
board…. the entire cast, is in perfect sync with the extreme emotional rhythms
of this symphonic mediation of war and its discontents. Holly Hunter is all
movement, hyper chatty, eyes bulging. She exudes an exquisite any
minute-on-the-verge-of-a-nervous breakdown vibe. This uncanny actress shows a
virtual color wheel of emotional variety. She makes you laugh, and chills to
the marrow in equal measure, sometimes simultaneously. Mr. Pullman equals Ms.
Hunter in a memorable reading of a man who is losing grip and seems to be
disappearing from within his own family. His incremental descent, perfectly
developed, is a marvel of technique. This actor has genuine craft that surpasses
the sense of watching someone reciting mere lines. He embodies the anguished
pain of this failed father with deeply resonant tones. Ben Schnetzer as David
is all Hell and Fury writ large. But this talented actor does wrangle and
wrestle and hit with a deep emotional punch. In one late-second act scene he
does indeed fight literally with Father Donald, as they spar in David’s
bedroom.
The play moves
inexorably toward a horrific dénouement. It makes complete sense to the family
at hand; the metaphor hangs like a stench of rotting flesh. The shock and
dismay of a torn country, the turning away from the young vet’s returning from
an emotionally scarring war, the complacency of the country, are all
beautifully captured in this surreal comic tragedy.
The Pershing Square
Signature Theater
480 West 42nd
Street, New York City
$77-$97. Ticket
Central (212) 279-4200
2 hours, 45 minutes
one intermission
Through December 14th