PHOTO BY
Richard Termine
By Elliot Rush
On March 13th, Sutton Foster, one
of Broadway’s reigning leading ladies, made a remarkable return to the stage of
Carnegie Hall as a guest of The New York Pops, just five days before her 40th
Birthday. In what became her penultimate number, Sutton told the packed crowd
that she is going to divert from the printed program and sing a song that she
now feels mature enough to sing. What else could that be? “Rose’s Turn” from Gypsy,
of course, one of the greatest show-stoppers of all time and Sutton did not
disappoint. She may not be the ideal musical theater actress to play the
character of Rose, at least not yet, but she did belt it out as great as the
best of them and she brought down the house. The elated audience cheered and
gave Sutton the first of three standing ovations. They also sang Happy
Birthday to her and for that short period, the 2800 seat theater became very
intimate. Sutton connects extremely well with her audience and the love
over-flowed back and forth. The evening was a love-fest.
Sutton Foster made her Carnegie Hall debut in
2005 as part of The New York Pops Birthday Gala and returned again in 2008 for
a concert celebrating the lyrics of Oscar Hammerstein II. This particular
night, however, was specifically designed to highlight her career and it was
put together by the multi-talented diva along with The New York Pop’s celebrated
musical director Steven Reinke. Sutton brought along a couple of friends to
perform with her on stage and this blissful evening of song and one tap dance
flew by much too quickly.
The New York Pops orchestra started the
evening off with the Overture from Anything Goes, performing a glorious
arrangement by Bill Elliott, the orchestrator of the 2011 Tony Award winning
revival that starred Sutton. What a pleasure to hear this music played by a 74
piece orchestra. Cole Porter never sounded better with the orchestra also
performing wonderful arrangements of “I’ve Got You Under My Skin” and “Begin
the Beguine.” Sutton gave the audience two numbers from Anything Goes,
the title song and “I Get A Kick Out of You,” the second show for which she won
a Tony Award.
The first half of the program included some
folk music; “Ashokan Farewell” by Jay Ungar featuring the concert mistress and
second violin and John Denver’s “Sunshine on My Shoulders,” sung softly and
beautifully by Sutton. She dedicated her performance of this song to her
mother who passed away in 2014 and was a huge fan of John Denver.
Surron Foster and Joshua Henry
Photo:Maryann Lopinto
The first of Sutton’s friends to perform was
Joshua Henry, a co-star of hers in last season’s Violet on Broadway.
Joshua performed a stirring rendition of Sam Cooke’s “A Change Is Gonna Come”
and was next joined on stage by Sutton, bringing an upbeat close to the first
half of the concert with “Fit As A Fiddle (and Ready for Love),” a rousing song
and tap dance that sent the audience out for intermission on a high.
The second half of Sutton’s evening opened
with the Overture to Thoroughly Modern Millie, a show for which she won
her first Tony Award. It is doubtful there is a better orchestra out there
anywhere performing Broadway and popular music. The Thoroughly Modern
Millie Overture was followed by another Overture, a compilation of TV Theme
Songs and this had a dazzling orchestration by Fred Barton. The audience could
be heard shouting out the names of the TV shows from which the theme songs
derived.
Sutton came back on stage in the second half
to sing a duet called “Flight” by Craig Carnelia with her best friend Megan
McGinnis and then gave the stage over to Megan who sang “Neverland” from Peter
Pan very poignantly. Joshua Henry also returned to sing “Let It Sing,” his
big number from the musical Violet.
For her final number, Sutton finished up the
program with a Stephen Sondheim medley; “Anyone Can Whistle” from Anyone Can
Whistle, a song she first sang in an Encores! presentation of the musical
back in 2010 and “Being Alive” from Company. This was a very powerful
performance and she received Standing Ovation number two Sutton was
additionally supported throughout the evening by her own personal musical
director and collaborator Michael Rafter who played the piano in the orchestra
and arranged several of her numbers. The evening would not have been complete
without an encore and that came with the song most audience members were
probably expecting to hear her sing: “Gimme, Gimme” from Thoroughly Modern
Millie. This is a number Sutton began quietly, built slowly to a full-out
belt and then, with arms out-stretched wide, she hit the final note with
remarkable power, sustained it indefinitely and, once again, brought down the
house. Standing Ovation number three.
This was a great night for Sutton. The
support she received from the orchestra was nothing less than stellar. Kudos
to everyone involved. Without question, The New York Pops are a New York
treasure and all of the concerts throughout their performance season are highly
anticipated. Here’s looking forward to the next.
Friday, April 10, 2015 at 8:00pm
Carnegie Hall, Stern Auditorium/Perelman Stage
Let’s Be Frank
Steven Reineke, Music Director and Conductor
Tony DeSare, Storm Large, Frankie Moreno, and Ryan Silverman,
Guest Artists
Monday, May 4, 2015 at 7:00pm
Carnegie Hall, Stern Auditorium / Perelman Stage
32nd Birthday Gala - THE NEW GOLDEN AGE
Steven Reineke, Music Director and Conductor
Kathleen Marshall, Music Honoree
Rob Marshall, Music Honoree
Carrie and Ted Pryor, Greenwich Harbor Partners, Corporate Honoree
For tickets, call CarnegieCharge at 212-247-7800 or visit
http://www.carnegiehall.org