Mountain Girl
Can deeply troubled characters find it in their hearts to forgive and to love each other? In Tony and Pulitzer Prize-winning playwright John Patrick Shanley’s Mountain Girl, that is indeed the question.
Now in its world premiere at 154 Theatre, the dark comedy takes an intense look at one broken young woman’s dysfunctional relationships with her husband and her mother, and the impact they’ve had on her unfulfilled life as an aspiring novelist with a severe writer’s block. It also considers the effects of exposed sexual activity and the legacy of trauma handed down from one generation to the next. Sound funny? That depends on your sense of humor. In this there is no Doubt.

The three-hander, directed by Ivette Dumeng, is centered on the unlikable characters’ over-the-top, ridiculous, combative behavior and nagging, unresolved issues with one another. It opens with a disheveled Connie (Sophia DeMornay-O’Neal) sprawled out on the sofa of her completely wrecked apartment in Bushwick. She’s scantily clad in black sequined hot pants (costumes by Janet Mervin), with a knot in her hair that she can’t get out, amidst a broken table, a knocked-over lamp and desk chair, a painting hanging crooked on the wall, and papers crumpled and strewn all over the floor. Not to mention drinking nonstop after ingesting Adderall…
When her husband Marty (Joey Welsh) arrives, she tells him the place was robbed, she called the police, and they did nothing. Marty — who has taken up writing a novel (the titular Mountain Girl), to inspire Connie — notices something significant in the mess though, and questions her about it. He reveals that he knows all about her secret life, which is why he is no longer intimate with her and wants a divorce. After an extended, laughably absurd, loud, and angry confrontation, Marty tells Connie to pack up and leave.
She has nowhere else to go, so heads out of Brooklyn to the upscale Colorado home of her estranged mother, Diana (Tonya Cornelisse), where she is clearly unwelcome. They rehash the past and the lies that caused their separation (let’s just say that Diana disowned her with good reason). Diana talks of her dashed hopes for Constance (as she calls her), noting her desire to be a writer since childhood, to tell the story of her inspirational hike up a mountain. They also discuss the grounds for her parents’ divorce, which, it turns out, are quite similar to her own, as both she and Diana were the subject of their respective husband’s erotic novels. Connie is allowed to spend the night in Diana’s camper, where a furious Marty shows up (again, with good reason).

While the story and its ongoing unhealthy relationships are far from believable (and presumably are why Mountain Girl is self-described as a “whacked, cracked comic fable”), the cast embraces the ludicrous characters and their preposterous conduct with full-blown commitment. DeMornay-O’Neal delivers Connie’s erotic writhing, posing, and straddling, her obvious lies, and her stymied life with a combination of passion and regret. Welsh is explosive in the loud and angry confrontations with his wife that result in her wielding a knife and him a gun – which turn out to be turn-ons for the sexually charged Connie (fight choreography and intimacy direction by Randall Rodriguez) – and then is loving in his desire to do everything he can to help her. And Cornelisse projects an overly refined, polar-opposite personality from her daughter, quoting classic literature and philosophy, wearing expensive negligees, serving Grand Marnier, and expressing her disappointment in her failed expectations of her daughter – until she comes to the realization of what they have in common and the effect it’s had.
Elizabeth Chaney’s set transitions easily from Connie and Marty’s messy apartment to Diana’s tasteful living room and her well-appointed camper where Connie spends the night. Lighting by Lucky Pearto and sound by Andy Evan Cohen enhance the locales and the moods, including ill-suited abstract segments of Neo-Expressionist movement to classical music between acts.
Will these characters forgive and love each other, and get the metaphorical knots out? Well, who else would want them? And it is a comedy, so…
Mountain Girl
At 154 Theatre
154 Christopher St.
Running time: 90 minutes, no intermission
Through November 28, 2026
