Photo by Lou Montesano..
by Marc Miller
Vivian Reed’s
set at the Metropolitan Room runs about an hour twenty, and how she gets
through it is anyone’s guess. A hard-working, old-school cabaret veteran with
Broadway experience (a Tony nomination for Bubbling Brown Sugar), she
displays an amazing, rangy voice, dances, growls, exhibits effusive body
language, dishes not-terribly-revealing anecdotes, and gives her able
four-piece band plenty of opportunity to shine. Her fans, a refreshingly
diverse and effusive bunch, cheer and whoop and talk back to her and give her
standing O’s. She’s magnificent. And she’s exhausting.
Her
Metropolitan show, “Standards & More,” is mostly standards, and came about,
she says, because audiences who love her in her usual R&B mode wanted to
see her do something else. Hence this very eclectic songlist, which melds
standards into medleys that are notable for their lack of logic. “Just One of
Those Things” is classic sassy Cole Porter, but what on earth does it have to
do with Lerner and Loewe’s exuberantly romantic “Almost Like Being in Love,” or
“I’m Gonna Live Till I Die,” an I-will-survive anthem punctuated by Reed with
additional defiance that isn’t in the sheet music (“I’m gonna laugh—HA!!!—till
I cry”)? She has to switch gears quickly, and does, but such juxtapositions
don’t add up to coherent declarations of mood or character. And she doesn’t do
vulnerable. Reed’s message throughout is: I’m in charge.
But she
really is, and if you can accept the relentless rush of confidence and vocal
pyrotechnics, you’ll have a grand time. Juilliard-trained, Reed has a fabulous
instrument; the deep is very deep and pure, the shift into head voice
invisible, the power in between formidable (though when her mic failed, she was
inaudible). She plays with melodies, improvising detours on “My Funny Valentine”
or “Believe in Yourself,” but respects the originals. And when given a chance
to make a statement—a harrowing “Strange Fruit,” abetted by wordless
accompaniment from guest artist Andrea Jones-Sojola, a poised soprano—she can
induce chills.
Reed’s backed
splendidly by William Foster McDaniel (piano), Gary Foote (bass), Damon
Duewhite (drums), and Erik Jacobson (cello; if we’re to believe her patter, she
picked him up after hearing him at Grand Central). All swing beautifully
through a Bubbling Brown Sugar medley of “Take the A Train,” “There’ll
Be Some Changes Made,” and a roof-raising “Sweet Georgia Brown”; it’s a
show-stopper. But Reed wants every number to be a show-stopper. Generally,
she succeeds; she’s that good. But laid-back isn’t in her repertoire, and
polished and mesmerizing as she is, we’d like to see more colors to her
palette. This becomes especially evident during a mic-free,
stroll-through-the-audience encore of “Mon Dieu,” part of an Edith Piaf tribute.
For once, Reed dials down on the emotional exuberance, lets the material speak
for itself, and reveals something approaching vulnerability. It strongly
suggests she can do just fine in a more reflective, less hard-charging mode.
But it’s followed by a “More” that shows off three octaves, punches the lyric
more than it needs to be punched, and seems designed to overwhelm. Vivian Reed
has overwhelming down pat.
She’s back at
the Metropolitan on September 26 and November 10, and by all means go. But
let’s hope that in the interim, she practices a little restraint.
Vivian Reed
appears at the Metropolitan Room, 34 W. 22nd St., New York;
metroplitanroom.com.