
Jagged
Little Pill
By Eugene Paul
Exploding
on to Broadway in an electrifying surge of amazing freshness and ingenuity,
marvelous veteran director Diane Paulus triumphantly weaves the raging teen
angst of famed Alanis Morrisette’s music into raging new relevance, through
wildly gifted Diablo Cody’s book of an achingly woke musical that is hilarious,
heart rending, painfully wise. You laugh, you cry, it’s a bitter pill to
swallow and it’s just what we need right now. All bow. There’s got to be some
way that everybody can afford to see it.
Meet
the Healys. No, first meet director Paulus’s secret weapon: her intense
company of dancers. Individually, every one of them shines in different roles
throughout the show, especially Ebony Williams, Antonio Cipriano, Yama
Perrault, Logan Hart, Heather Lang, Kei Tsuriharatani, Max Kumangai, but
together, over and over, they are a frenzy of underscoring what the show is
about. Now, meet the Healys, because they are the heart, the core. They’re
doing their annual Christmas card right at us. There’s beautiful Mom, Mary
Jane (stunning Elizabeth Stanley), handsome Dad, Steve ( superb Sean Allan
Krill), perfect son, Nick (sterling Derek Klena) and little sixteen year old
beautiful baby sister, Frankie (outrageous Celia Rose Gooding). All privileged
overachievers. Of course.

Elizabeth
Stanley and Celia Rose Gooding in "Jagged Little Pill." Matthew
Murphy
Which
means that Frankie champions Causes, marches, makes posters, protests. She
stands out. She ought to, she’s black. Adopted. And as much as Mom wants her
to fit in, Frankie knows she doesn’t. Thank god for a sense of humor. A sense
of humor would help Nick because he’s Perfect and it’s a strain. Of course he
gets into Harvard. And it’s a worse strain. Strain? Steve knows strain. Steve,
Daddy Steve, works sixty hours a week for his law firm. Yada yada yada that’s
where the money is, but that’s not where the family is. And Mom, perfect Mom
Mary Jane, is cracking.
You’ve
stopped being amazed at how well the Morrisette songs fit in. You accept that
everyone is super multitalented, sings like sixty, acts like ninety, gets to us
like a hundred. You are accepting that the frantic dancers are expressing your
inner feelings in choreographer Sidi Lardi Cherkaoui’s fevered underlinings
director Paulus has demanded. It all seems so right they also take you to
myriad configurations whirling brilliant set designer Riccardo Hernandez’s
constantly fluid set pieces into continuous flow of scene after scene after
scene.
Everything’s
been so clever, so witty, so funny you sense a queasy alarm when Mom Mary Jane
needs more and more of those pain pills. And when the phony prescriptions don’t
work any more, there’s the skateboard kid in the alley with more pills for
cash, lotsa cash. No wonder she’s not aware that Frankie has found a wonderful
kindred spirit, Jo (dazzling Lauren Patten), but would she be aware anyway?
Nick is finding the demands of being the perfect son perfectly lousy and Dad
Steve blames himself for everything slipping away. Little does he know. But
director Paulus’s wild and passionate dancers
know. And so do we.

Derek
Klena
So
that when perfect Nick is persuaded to go to that drinking party his best bud
has been pushing, the dancers get wilder. And when Nick finds his baby sister
there, we are Involved. We’re almost ready to laugh a bit when Frankie hooks up
with flavor of the moment Phoenix (Antonio Cipriano) until her girl friend, Jo,
discovers them but Jo’s passion is so real it ain’t funny at all. Then, things
get bad.
Which
suits the Alanis Morrisette/Glen Ballard song book perfectly. And literally
brings the audience to its feet when Jo sings, performs her guts out in a
Morrisette song as if written for the moment. Because by now, we care. We care
about Mary Jane ‘s dark history that erupts after years of concealment. We care
about every one of the Healys. And maybe most of all, we care about those kids
at that party, especially Bella (extraordinary Kathryn Gallagher), raped,
helplessly drunk. Is it all too much, beyond handling? Then how are we to
survive?
And
that’s the great question you never wanted to confront, especially going out
for a fun evening at the theater. It’s not revealing too much to tell you that
the company sings “You Learn” for the final number. Because that’s what we
do. We have to. What a show. Kudos all around: Tom Kitt for tuned in music
supervising, Emily Rebholz for tuned in costumes, Justin Townsend for nailing
lighting, Jonathan Deans for swooning sound, Bryan Perri for leading that
tremendous band. And especially Diane Paulus, directing myriad elements e
pluribus unum. What a show. I know. I said that already. Enjoy. Lucky you.
Jggged
Little Pill. At
the Broadhurst Theatre, 235 West 44th Street. Tickets: $59-$399.
212-239-6200. 2rs, 40 min. Open Run.