Kate Baldwin & Conor Ryan photos
by Carol Rosegg
by Joel Benjamin
Andrew Lippa and Tom
Greenwald’s John & Jen at the Clurman Theatre is a chamber musical
that bursts with emotion. Kate Baldwin, an extraordinary actor/singer joins
newcomer Conor Ryan in a tale that spans decades. J&J explores the
complexities of blood relationships here tinged with unconscious obsessive,
possibly incestuous, overtones. In the first act, John (Mr. Ryan) is Jen’s
(Ms. Baldwin’s) brother and in the second he is Jen’s son, his uncle’s namesake,
John. Jen can’t seem to find a healthy way to relate to either one. Her inner
emotional turmoil is the subject of John & Jen which takes her from
her childhood attachment to her sibling to her smother-love for her son.
Photos by Carol Rosegg
Act One finds Jen, older
sister to her cherished John, having to take on parental duties after they live
through the breakup of their parents’ marriage. We see her reaction to his
birth—“Welcome to the World”—and an early Christmas—“Christmas I.” Jen tries
to placate John and support him through the thick and thin of their parents’
problems. His love of baseball becomes important to her. As he grows up they
reach an impasse that leads to his tragic death: “Out of My Sight” and “Run
& Hide.”
In Act Two Jen has idealized
her brother, naming her son after him. Her marriage in shambles, she channels
her energies toward him, unconsciously (or not?) turning him into a living
substitute for her brother. She forces baseball on him by giving him her
brother’s old baseball glove—“Christmas II” & “Little League.” In the latter
song, she becomes the baseball equivalent of a stage mother, leading to
friction that gets worse and worse until Jen has an eye-opening revelation that
leads to an uneasy self-understanding—“Every Goodbye is Hello.”
The songs range from straight-forward
storytelling to explorations of the minds and emotions of the characters, all
done with agreeable melodies and styles ranging from Rodgers & Hammerstein
to Sondheim. Lippa and Greenwald sculpted these songs to keep the story
rolling along easily and expressively. There is humor, wit as well as sadness
in these beautifully sung works.
Both performers acquitted
themselves beautifully. Young Mr. Ryan with his boyish good looks managed the
transformations required with aplomb, going from lanky youngster to troubled
adult and back to youngster. Ms. Baldwin somehow magically became the young
Jen and then the mom, all with just the slightest changes in posture and
voice. The actors were—refreshingly—unamplified, easily heard over the
on-stage band led by music director Lily Ling who was joined by Melanie Mason
on cello.
Steven C. Kemp’s set was too
abstract, consisting of angular grey walls splotched with vague colors,
punctuated by three ramps which served as beds, outdoor patches and gravesites.
The show needed a real sense of place and period, which this scenery failed to
provide. Were they poor, middle class? Was their house large, small? None of
this was answered, although Sydney Maresca’s costumes and the props designed by
Ricola Wille and Julia Moreno helped.
John & Jen is a small show with big emotions,
illuminated through the writing of Lippa and Greenwald and given life by Conor
Ryan and Kate Baldwin.
John & Jen – through April 4,, 2015
Clurman Theatre at Theatre
Row
410 West 42nd
St., just west of 9th Ave.
New York, NY
Tickets: 212-239-6200 or www.telecharge.com
Running time: 2 hours, one
intermission
More information: www.keencompany.org