The Fantasticks
The Fantasticks is one of the world’s few perfect musicals, and anyone who messes with it will have me to answer to. That the messer-in-chief for the Second Stage’s revisal at the Hayes Theater is Tom Jones, the original librettist and lyricist, is no guarantee it’s in safe hands. The Fantasticks has always been a miniature show, and ratcheting it up to even a small Broadway house carries risks. So does the manifold gender-flipping it’s been subjected to, and turning young lovers Matt and Luisa into Matt and Lewis does generate some awkwardnesses. But in the end, it’s still The Fantasticks. And The Fantasticks is still an enchantment.
You probably know its storied history. The Fantasticks, featuring indelible music by Harvey Schmidt, opened at the tiny Sullivan Street Playhouse on May 3, 1960, to mixed reviews and underpopulated audiences. Then some recording artists discovered its score and started covering its songs — if you’ve never heard the young Barbra Streisand’s “Soon It’s Gonna Rain,” stop reading this and track it down right now — and turned the show into a hit.
It ran a record-smashing 42 years, became one of the most performed musicals ever, was revived in 2006 and ran into 2017. A meditation on young love, painful life lessons, and how, “without a hurt, the heart is hollow,” it employs commedia dell’arte, Noh, magic, and minimal production values, and its text and lyrics shimmer with a poetry that many musicals have attempted to imitate, and none has ever matched.

For any Fantasticks addict, a first look at the Hayes stage is welcoming: a ragged sheet displaying its famous logo; a harp; an upright piano; a ghost light, and a trunk marked Sullivan Street Playhouse. The Mute (Ahmad Simmons) enters, the overture starts, and soon it’s evident that this Fantasticks will be larger than usual.
Whatever happened to piano, harp, percussion? It’s now an eight-piece offstage ensemble, orchestrated by Sam Davis, and while we love the simple originals, this is an improvement—gentle, heavy on the strings, and kind to the vocalists. Jason Sherwood’s set, small for Broadway, is large for The Fantasticks, with a big gray upstage wall, gardens that roll in and out, and greenery dropping from the rafters for “Soon It’s Gonna Rain.” Linda Cho’s mostly prosaic costumes deliver a couple of eye-poppers after intermission, and Jen Schriever’s lighting turns luminous shades of red and blue. Bravo to Nevin Steinberg’s sound design, which keeps the voices natural and audible.
I wondered how Jones, who completed this adaptation before his 2023 passing, would rewrite Luisa’s desire to “go to town in a golden gown”; Lewis (Nathan Levy) trades the golden gown for a golden crown, and most of Jones’s revisions are similarly sensible. Lewis loves Matt (Maxim Chlumecky), the slightly older boy next door, it’s mutual, and their parents are feigning a neighborly battle to assure their sons end up together, since “to manipulate children, you merely say ‘no.’”
The fathers of the original have been transformed into mothers, Mildred (Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer) and Bessie Mae (usually Ruthie Ann Miles; here, understudy Michele Ragusa who was a riot). To seal the deal, they hire El Gallo (Zane Phillips, a Tom of Finland of an El Gallo, with insane biceps, a ’70s stache, and a sturdy baritone) to stage an abduction of Lewis, which Matt will foil to unite the families. El Gallo is assisted by The Old Actor (a wonderful David Patrick Kelly), constantly brandishing his clippings and misquoting Shakespeare, and his sidekick Mortimer (an adorable Kevin Del Aguila), whose specialty is death scenes — “die for the man, Mortimer!”

The abduction goes well, and as directed by Christopher Gattelli it’s a honey, with surprising props and slapstick moves that leave the audience cheering. But daylight—Act One’s in moonlight, Act Two’s in the sun—brings disillusions and dissatisfactions, and Matt and Lewis have to find their way back to one another. Or, as El Gallo puts it, “we must all die a bit before we’re born again.”
Now, about turning Luisa into Lewis. The Fantasticks has always existed out of time and place; it’s a fable lacking a culturally specific setting. That said, for 99.99% of human existence, most parents would have wished for their sons to marry some nice girl, and the same-sex pairing here does take some getting used to. Especially as Levy’s Lewis is wispy and wimpy, and for most of the first act I was thinking, get out into the world, Matt, you can do better for yourself.
Levy won me over by about “Soon It’s Gonna Rain,” and the final tableau, with the two young lovers hand in hand silhouetted against a blue sky, is richly satisfying. But be aware, a same-sex Fantasticks does play differently, not all the revisions are perfect fits, and the Act Two kiss between Lewis and El Gallo actually felt a little creepy.

Chlumecky’s Matt is about three-quarters there — he needs to hone his comic chops. He’ll get there, and everyone else, bravissimo. Gattelli’s vaudevillian choreography for the moms’ “Never Say No” is a particular highlight, and I also loved how, in “Plant a Radish,” the feuding parents begin on opposite sides of the stage, work their way toward each other, and end in an embrace. But there are staging missteps, too. Why, during “This Plum Is Too Ripe,” is the Mute soft-shoeing? And “Round and Round,” sad to say, is a disaster: confusingly staged, with vital text removed, and Lewis’s tenor cadenzas against El Gallo’s baritone just don’t have the ping of a soprano Luisa.
But oh, those songs. The ballads are heaven, the choral work is intricate and ear-tickling, and it was a particular delight to hear the comic numbers winning such huge laughs. I’m an easy Fantasticks mark; I was weeping by the end of “Try to Remember” and got misty again through “Metaphor,” “Rain,” and “They Were You.” Jones and Schmidt’s revision of “It Depends on What You Pay,” whose original version was slapped down by the PC Police decades back, works just fine, and is there a finer “I want” song in all of musical theater than “Much More”?
To my antiquated way of thinking, there’s nothing wrong with the Fantasticks that ran on Sullivan Street for four decades-plus. But this rethinking remains, by and large, fantastick.
The Fantasticks
At The Hayes Theater, Second Stage
240 W. 44th St.
Running time: 2 hours 5 minutes, 1 intermission
Through February 7, 2027
